Originally
posted by
Dragonlance:
On top of that the filter does not target any political content at all. It only targets child porn sites, + some adult material/lots of sites that were placed wrongly on the blacklist due to incompetence..
I seriously doubt Stephen Conroy, as stupid as he is, would be able to get much off the ground regarding the filter, given it alienates so many who should be labor party faithful, and is so blatently not in line with general labor policy on other tech issues such as R18+ games rating and NBN etc.
I think will take forever to launch as well. Though if you actually read the legislation in regards to the classification laws.
1.) unrated material is technically illegal unless it has approval to be unrated. The majority of pages accessed by Australians are unrated and therefore could be filtered. (obviously you've never used the governments filters before, that block sites for obscure reasons) You will have to give them the benefit of the doubt that they won't filter unrated content like they have in past.
2.) Issues such as euthenasia are filtered because they are illegal, as well as certain abortion drug information is filtered as its semi-illegal.
3.) yes you were correct about the incompetence, thats the most disturbing thing, if your business's site is blacklisted by mistake you have no way of knowing and very little means of appeal.
4.) the filter won't actually stop the illegal material that it was designed to stop, as it has already been shown by consultants that its easy to bipass with certain setups, eg proxies, p2p, etc.
Will it be successful, I don't think so as well, I agree with you that in the current climate it will be quite hard to put forward. They are/were doing so to try and win the votes of the religious right. However they haven't abandoned the policy and they have successfully trialled in in certain states/isps.
Rofl as for calling them the communist party, it was because I once met a bunch of dudes that just went on and on about how they hated labor lol. It was quite funny the conspiracy theories they had about the government. So I just included it for laughs to see what happened.