Jul 1st 2012, 14:19:40
Well, it's not necessarily Republic vs. Farmer.
It's really Casher vs. Farmer.
Neither is necessarily better, but based on how market conditions go in a set, one will end up being better.
As stated in the previous post, Casher is a strategy based on getting as many people as possible and raising their Per Capita Income (PCI) as high as possible so you can bring in large amounts of tax dollars. With those tax dollars, you buy all the other goods/tech you need. Republic is often the best/easiest government type for Casher because Republic offers a PCI bonus for your citizen. Some people might argue Democracy is better, but you have to get your tech levels incredibly high to really take advantage of Democracy bonuses, so for a beginner player, Republic is a far better choice.
Farmer is a strategy based around building virtually nothing but farms and then selling your excess food in order to buy the other things you need (military/tech/oil). The reason I would recommend Democracy or Fascism is because Fascism gets a food and oil production bonus and Democracy pays 0% commissions and has a higher maximum technology level, so between not losing 6% on each bushel and being able to top out your tech levels and produce more than most other governments, you'll do best with those.